August 2018


Issue Home >>

 

Regional Tobacco Tax Harmonization

A High-Level Knowledge Exchange Conference on Regional Tobacco Tax Harmonization in the Caribbean was organized by the World Bank Group’s Tobacco Control Program, under the leadership of Patricio Marquez and The UWI, HEU, Centre for Health Economics, under the leadership of Prof Karl Theodore.

The purpose of the Conference was to discuss the way forward for tobacco tax harmonization across the OECS region, based on the experiences and lessons learned from other customs unions across the world. The Conference was envisaged to be the starting point of tobacco tax harmonization discussion in the region and was born out of a recently drafted report on the state of excise taxes in the OECS region. The Report was drafted by the HEU-UWI, in collaboration with the World Bank Tobacco Team, and with data generated by the Statistical offices and Customs and Excise Divisions of participating OECS member countries. Included in the report were simulations on harmonization scenarios for 2019 to 2021.

The Conference was attended by representatives from;

  • World Bank Group’s Tobacco Control Program;
  • The UWI, St. Augustine Campus;
  • Organization of Eastern Caribbean States (OECS) Secretariat;
  • Ministry of Health and Ministry of Finance officials from the OECS and Trinidad and Tobago;
  • CARICOM (Caribbean Community);
  • Pan American Health Organization/World Health Organization;
  • European Union (EU);
  • West African Economic and Monetary Union (WAEMU); and
  • The Economics of Tobacco Control Project team, Cape Town University, South Africa.

Among the subjects discussed:

Draft report on, Advancing Action on the Implementation of Tobacco tax Harmonization in the OECS.

  • Each country was invited to give their thoughts on the report, the applicability of the findings in their respective contexts, and potential commitments to harmonizing tobacco excise taxes.
  • There was a general consensus that the harmonized rate should be set as a minimum (price floor) where individual countries could exercise freedom in setting a higher excise tax level based on country’s agenda.
  • Participating countries indicated that there was strong political will for strengthening tobacco taxation and an effort to harmonize tobacco taxation would be timely, given that tobacco tax reform discussions have been on-going in many countries.
  • To achieve the health status goals, it was identified that the increase in taxation translates into retail price increase i.e. cigarettes should become less affordable over time to deter initiation and encourage cessation.
  • It was also suggested that excise tax increases be publicized so that the public could pre-emptively change its smoking behaviour.

Applicability and effect of the tax harmonization at the OECS regional level

  • Currently tobacco control policies are determined at the national level with different tax structures, levels of taxation, and processes for tax collection. While there are currently five different types of taxes are applied on tobacco products across the region, the proposal is to rationalise to three types of taxes: Customs (CET), VAT and excise tax.
  • The exact taxation rate that will fit all of the countries in the region will need to be assessed.
  • It was widely believed that simpler tax systems are better than more complex taxes. A uniform specific tax that is adjusted regularly for inflation and income growth is regarded as best practice.

Illicit tobacco trade in the Caribbean region

  • While concerns were raised about the illicit trade in the region and the impact on tax revenues, stronger port controls and legislation were identified as measures to minimize such trade.

Availability of data and data monitoring in the region

  • A lack of data hinders tobacco control policy and monitoring. It was suggested that a data repository for the region be created.

Earmarking excise tax revenues; tobacco tax revenues

  • Some countries favoured earmarking revenues specifically for healthcare as well as smoking cessation programmes.

The Conference was held on June 21and 22 at the HEU, Centre for Health Economics, Sir George Alleyne Building, 25A Warner Street, St. Augustine